Someone stole your toolbox – what do you do?

You’ve been using it for years. Every tool in your kit has your name on it – even if you’re not a fiend with a labeler, people know the kinds of work you do, the kind of quality you produce. An integral part of that quality comes from knowing your tools, knowing what they can do, and making sure you approach tasks from a uniform position.

Uniform positions are the helpdesk approach to problem solving; rational elimination by rote.

You’ve made the helpdesk call, right? We all have. You ask for help, and the person on the other end runs through what amounts to a probability tree involving try-this-then-that procedures. The whole experience usually feels very Monty Hall in its predictable lack of reliable result. The root of the problem here is that it’s all done by rote. It’s trained, and it’s not imaginative.

The help desk mentality is killing creative thinking!

I’ve got nothing against Helpdeskers – their training is important in many situations. However, when we can’t ask for help, and don’t have access to their resources, we’re limited to what we know.

But what do we do when we don’t know anything?

You’ve just been given a new job. You’re getting down to business, preparing yourself for the work ahead – but something’s horribly wrong. It takes you a while to realize what’s going on, but eventually it comes to you; for some reason, your usual approach is useless here. Someone has, effectively, stolen your toolbox.

Everyone faces this now and then.

It could be a literal tool, or a common process – the tool itself doesn’t matter, what matters is that you can’t fix a problem in the usual manner. So what do you do? This is where most people spend hours thrashing away at new ideas, building new methods, or thinking outside the box. It usually goes nowhere – but there’s an easy way to fix that, and some simple questions to ask before you dig in.

Are you addressing the process, or the problem?

More often than not, we look for ways to fit our usual process into the needs of a job, not the other way around.How can you tell if this is happening? Look for these signs;

  • If you’re thinking in terms of steps, strategy or plans – you’re addressing process.
  • If you’re trashing, spending a lot of time thinking about details – you’re addressing process.

Try adjusting to focus in these areas instead;

  • If you’re looking at the history leading up to the problem, that’s addressing the problem.
  • If you’re looking for new materials to use, that’s addressing a problem.
  • If you’re willing (if you have time) to step away from the task to reconsider, you’re willing to address the problem itself properly.

Of course, these are broad examples – they can’t possibly be anything else. After all, addressing high-level concerns immediately means removing yourself from the process, which is all your usual tools are good for. Grooming yourself for high-level thinking is an excellent way to approach problems instead of processes. Simple motivators can make a huge difference.

The Cult of Done Manifesto hangs over an innumerable number of desks, for good reason. It teaches us to focus on results above process, and to finish before we perfect. The perfect is the enemy of the done!

The Pie Chart of Procrastination is another example of simple messages; the details are meaningless without action!

Above all else, being willing to accept new tools is one of the best problem solving skills out there.

So I’ll leave it with you; what tools do you use, that you’ve found don’t actually apply to every situation you thought they did?

Ian M Rountree is a blogger and marketing professional who is currently publishing a web novel, The Dowager Shadow.

No related posts.

8 Responses to Someone stole your toolbox – what do you do?
  1. KatFrench
    April 7, 2010 | 9:24 am

    Wow, this was really relevant to me, Ian. It feels like my toolbox gets iteratively replaced about every six months in my line of work (social media). I can definitely see how focusing on the current problem, instead of trying to perfect a process that is constantly going to need to evolve, is a better way. Really good stuff, man!

    • Ian M Rountree
      April 7, 2010 | 1:53 pm

      Thanks, Kat! I agree – for anyone working in technology, this seems to happen a lot. Part of my training for my current position included a procedural approach, rather than a tools-based one, which was incredibly foreign and against my previous knowledge. I think developing procedure (conceptually) rather than process (action-based) proves itself in a lot of situations to be more sustainable over time.

      Glad you liked the article!

  2. Mark Dykeman
    April 7, 2010 | 11:08 am

    Wow. Ian’s final question is hard to answer because it’s quite broad. I’m reminded of the following phrase, though: “if your only tool is a hammer, then you will treat every problem as a nail.”

    I think that one problem that some people fall into, including introverts, is that you have logically satisfying solutions and then you have emotionally satisfying solutions. For example, people don’t always just want an answer to a question or a problem: they want an accompanying feeling or method of delivery that makes them happy (yes, that could mean silver platters…)

    That’s why the best CSRs can deliver bad news with empathy and compassion in such a way that the customer doesn’t blow a gasket while the worst CSRs can deliver great news in a cold or callous way that upsets the customer. Gender differences could possibly be a factor here as well (not always, just perhaps in certain situations). So, to sum it up, logic and rational thinking don’t always carry the day and we may have to turn to soft skills to resolve problems.

    There’s also the classic examples of throwing technology at problems which are really more about work processes or interpersonal problems…

    I think, though, one of the keys to being a successful problem solver is that ability to figure out when you need to abandon the standard tool set and examine the problem on its own merits. This can be a challenge when organizations are accounting for time not just in hours or minutes, but in seconds.

    Great ideas, Ian!

    • Ian M Rountree
      April 7, 2010 | 2:17 pm

      “you have logically satisfying solutions and then you have emotionally satisfying solutions”

      Very good point! CSRs are in an awful position for this, I agree. It takes a certain skill for delivery that’s under-appreciated.

      Glad you liked it – and for the suggestions!

  3. Rebecca Leaman
    April 7, 2010 | 6:18 pm

    The same thought came to my mind as to Mark’s: “if your only tool is a hammer, then you will treat every problem as a nail.” Part of the challenge is not only to discern which problems are nails and which are screws, to extend the metaphor, but to recognize whether the nail (if it is indeed a nail) is actually a problem. Or at least the same problem you think it is… but I digress.

    From the point of view of problem solving without the toolbox, it does seem that we often confuse the tools used to solve a problem with the actual process of solving the problem. As you say, Ian, “Above all else, being willing to accept new tools is one of the best problem solving skills out there.” Agreed! If the problem is a bent nail, what’s fundamentally important is the hammering on the nail to straighten it out, right? So the creative (and successful) problem solver would be he who, finding his hammer gone, instinctively looks around for a nice big rock.

  4. Bill Wren
    April 8, 2010 | 8:09 am

    I think we have a natural inclination to return again and again to what worked previously when a problem arises. But when we see it doesn’t apply, how we respond is what determines how successful we’ll be at finding an answer.

    I think the creative response always starts with a kind of elation at the idea of having to find something new. It’s curiosity and an eagerness to learn that leads to discovery and answers. In a way, it’s exciting to lose the toolbox because now your head can really get into gear.

  5. [...] of the big deals with problem solving is building a tool kit (or a toolbox) and gathering better ideas. Being able to see clearly the merit of a piece of advice situationally [...]

  6. [...] all the way to the end…  I’m planning a contest to celebrate all of our commentators! Someone stole your toolbox – what do you do? by Ian M. [...]

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

CommentLuv badge

Trackback URL http://thoughtwrestling.com/blog/problem-solving-tool-process-fixes/trackback/